{ "schema": "bayandin-v5-independent-visual-style-review/v1", "date": "2026-10-08T12:39:03.497Z", "reviewer": "adversarial_auditor", "status": "PASS for classic terrain layout/empty sites and current atmosphere logic; new full v5 component assembly is outside this background pass.", "activeAssetsChangedByReviewer": false, "sharedBrowserUsed": false, "openConfirmedTerrainDefects": 0, "openConfirmedAtmosphereLogicDefects": 0, "inputs": { "terrain": { "path": "source/v5/terrain-classic.png", "sha256": "fc9d86b938b86aae868c57b9912b98cb9d9ff30ec722b81dc6fe6cff3157816d", "width": 1672, "height": 941 }, "acceptedV4Ground": { "path": "source/v4/ground-repair-v2/ground-final-candidate.png", "sha256": "ed122711b7d30e5570b529dcdb4e6e87cf2c8886e7a927c60047749b00dd3166", "width": 2048, "height": 1152 }, "scene": { "path": "source/v5/candidate/scene.json", "sha256": "99fa002af9bb4dd2777d68040d574adf16a4b0a7358e05e5288e123abf4530fa" }, "atmosphere": { "path": "source/v5/candidate/atmosphere.js", "sha256": "4952d0ff74ca59e8e4b66bea47aabee8d371fac49bfd2d158808f8ab0659f9fd" }, "cloud": { "path": "assets/v5/clouds.png", "sha256": "ed2e1e216cd911613749b1647b0004d2a2c9f6b98928b73b84078266f4ae7ee5" } }, "methodology": [ "Compared complete native backgrounds side by side.", "Normalized only read-only QA crops to 2048x1152 world coordinates, then enlarged all13 footprint/roof-frame unions and context/gate/road regions.", "Checked candidate 141 exact raw ground polygons,13 roof frames/visual contours and both mapped gates against frozen v5 geography.", "Loaded source modules in an isolated VM: checked metadata disabling, moved-building protection, clock lifecycle and SVG mask alpha at two times plus moved11." ], "style": { "chosen": "classic city-builder", "result": "Coherent crisp crowns, brighter controlled greens, warm paving and readable road markings. No embedded fog/clouds/grid/UI/text. The geographical composition and source apparent near-nadir context camera remain comparable to v4.", "evidence": [ "terrain-classic.png", "qa/independent-style/terrain-clouds-t0.png" ] }, "all13TerrainSites": [ { "id": "building-3", "code": "3", "ordinaryFloors": 3, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Long irregular east/south site remains flat paving. Thin bright street-side edge retained from v4; no distinct raised facade or rooftop seen.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-3-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-3-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-4", "code": "4", "ordinaryFloors": 6, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Empty H/spine site retained. Fixed southwest neighbor is still separate. No rebuilt main/wing mass remains in terrain.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-4-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-4-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-6A", "code": "6А", "ordinaryFloors": 2, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Low-body site remains flat, with existing car/service edge and adjacent trees. No second reception block.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-6A-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-6A-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-6", "code": "6", "ordinaryFloors": 3, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Irregular long site preserved; neighboring small utility roofs/courtyard are not erased or duplicated.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-6-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-6-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-8", "code": "8", "ordinaryFloors": 2, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Compact pitched-roof component site is empty. Existing light edge reads as flat paving; no old pitched mass reintroduced.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-8-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-8-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-9", "code": "9", "ordinaryFloors": 5, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Long southern site remains empty. Small light edge and paving markings do not create a raised five-floor body or new wing.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-9-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-9-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-10", "code": "10", "ordinaryFloors": 6, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Principal narrow rectangular site empty, without the earlier invented western wing or a separate replacement body.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-10-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-10-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-11", "code": "11", "ordinaryFloors": 9, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Long main site flat. No former raised white end wall, roofing fixtures or strong dark crescent near food.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-11-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-11-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-13", "code": "13", "ordinaryFloors": 4, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Long northern site stays flat. Small protected covered passage and neighboring utilities still present.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-13-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-13-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-14", "code": "14", "ordinaryFloors": 4, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "East administrative site empty. Thin bright edge has no separate facade plane, rooftop or ordinary window rows.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-14-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-14-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-16", "code": "16", "ordinaryFloors": 3, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Small northeast site shows natural uneven ground/planting. No old white southeast wall, stepped shadow or roof fragment.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-16-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-16-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-29a", "code": "29а", "ordinaryFloors": 2, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Complete upper compact block plus connecting/branching site remains empty. Separate forensic neighbor is preserved; no old stair/roof mass.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-29a-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-29a-v5.png" ] }, { "id": "building-food", "code": "ПБ", "ordinaryFloors": 2, "status": "PASS: empty ground site retained", "review": "Food site flat, with preserved neighboring facade and courtyard. No reinstated food roof or new raised slab.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/building-food-v4.png", "qa/independent-style/building-food-v5.png" ] } ], "context": [ { "instance": "Гвардейская 22 / osm-way-44053767", "sourceFloors": 9, "status": "No confirmed low-rise substitution", "review": "Original narrow flat-roof bar, roof furniture and source apparent wall depth retained. Individual nine window rows cannot be certified from this near-nadir background raster." }, { "instance": "Гвардейская 24 / osm-way-44053768", "sourceFloors": 9, "status": "No confirmed low-rise substitution", "review": "Original longer flat-roof bar and courtyard relationship retained. No new house or shortened footprint seen; fine floor rows not countable." } ], "roadsAndGates": { "status": "PASS", "mainWorld": [ 731.878, 1000.486 ], "secondaryWorld": [ 732.148, 636.305 ], "secondaryMappedServiceCenterlinePreserved": true, "review": "Main curved junction, zebra crossing, Pavlova alignment and narrow under-canopy secondary service clarification remain in the same visual locations. No proposed move of a gate or change to source route geometry.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/gate-main-v5.png", "qa/independent-style/gate-secondary-v5.png", "qa/independent-style/road-Pavlova-v5.png" ], "limits": "Texture and lane/paving materials are artistic. OSM does not establish actual service width, paving, current access rules or exclusive entry/exit direction." }, "geography": { "count": 141, "groundDifferences": [], "frameDifferences": [], "visualContourDifferences": [], "gateDifferences": [] }, "findings": [ { "id": "V5-ATM-01", "severity": "P2 implementation consistency", "instance": "atmosphere.draw / scene.world.atmosphere.enabled", "status": "Resolved by root and independently rechecked", "finding": "Earlier Canvas draw respected only the call enabled flag, while SVG also respected atmosphere.enabled=false. No effect in current enabled:true scene, but metadata-disabled Canvas/SVG differed.", "correction": "Root added scene.world.atmosphere?.enabled===false to Canvas early return.", "verification": "VM now observes0 Canvas image calls and empty SVG with disabled metadata.", "evidence": "qa/independent-style/atmosphere-qa.json" } ], "atmosphere": { "status": "PASS for reviewed logic and static mask images", "hospitalOcclusion": "0 cloud-alpha samples inside protected hospital areas at t0, t173 and moved11. Counts include repeated samples where protected rectangles overlap.", "movedBuildingProtection": { "building": "building-11", "expectedDelta": [ -518.2570000000001, -140.13099999999997 ], "observedProtectedRectDelta": [ -518.2570000000001, -140.13099999999997 ], "pass": true }, "clock": { "cadenceMs": 100, "hiddenTimers": 0, "disabledTimers": 0, "reducedMotionTimers": 0, "resumedTimers": 1, "destroyedTimers": 0, "destroyedListeners": 0, "elapsedBeforeHidden": 0.1, "elapsedAfterHidden": 0.1, "invalidations": 8, "pass": true }, "hitTesting": "SVG atmospheric group uses pointer-events=none; Canvas clouds are decoration and absent from model hit candidates. Editor passes translated model.getScene() to protection.", "performance": "Six cloud image draws,13 clipping holes,100ms invalidation cadence and RAF coalescing. Timer stops while hidden, disabled or reduced-motion; no elapsed catch-up after a hidden interval. Actual browser/GPU frame cost is not measured by this VM/SVG audit.", "evidence": [ "qa/independent-style/atmosphere-qa.json", "qa/independent-style/terrain-clouds-t0.png", "qa/independent-style/terrain-clouds-t173.png", "qa/independent-style/terrain-clouds-moved11.png" ] }, "requiredCorrections": [], "nextAssemblyChecks": [ "After all new sprites are registered, inspect the assembled v5 scene for foundation contact, roof silhouette/wing fidelity, floor counts and matching camera/style.", "Root dynamic candidate review should cover pan/zoom, moving a component under a cloud, cloud toggle and PNG export." ], "limits": [ "No raster pixel identity claimed for full-image generative restyling. Exact immutable vector payloads passed; raster alignment is visual within this pass.", "Native terrain is1672x941; world/4K export upscaling does not add genuine terrain detail.", "This pass does not certify new sprite11/9/8 floor counts or future full13 replacement assets.", "Context9-floor data remains sourced, while nine rows are not visible enough to count in near-nadir context roofs.", "Concealed ground reconstruction, roof/facade materials and precise window placement remain artistic, not surveyed.", "No shared Safari or active UI/assets changed." ] }